Evidence Ratings: Does It Actually Work?
A single, honest scorecard for the recovery and tissue-repair interventions we have covered in depth: what the research actually supports, graded on the same five-tier scale we use throughout our articles.
Every rating below reflects that article’s own headline claim and its own cited research, graded using our published evidence tiers: Strong, Moderate, Preliminary, Preclinical, and Insufficient. We never upgrade a claim to look more certain than the underlying studies support, and we never invent a grade. See our editorial and evidence standards for exactly what each tier means and how we assign it.
This index currently rates our Recovery & Tissue Repair articles, the only topic hub we have fully published so far. We will add ratings for longevity, mobility and pain, weight and metabolic health, and hormone and vitality as those hubs go live.
The ratings, strongest to weakest
One row per intervention we have reviewed. Tap through to the full article for the citations behind each grade.
Progressive loading is the best-evidenced tendinopathy treatment. Eccentric training and heavy slow resistance perform comparably in a head-to-head trial, so the protocol you actually stick with matters more than which one you pick.
Read the evidenceVitamin C and protein: the building blocks of collagen
Evidence: StrongVitamin C is a well-established, non-negotiable cofactor for building collagen. Most people already meet these needs through a varied diet, and timed supplementation around exercise only adds a modest extra benefit.
Read the evidencePEACE & LOVE vs. RICE for acute injury
Evidence: ModerateSports-medicine guidance has shifted from RICE to the PEACE & LOVE framework: protect briefly, then load early, and avoid routinely icing or medicating away inflammation.
Read the evidenceIcing and anti-inflammatories after training
Evidence: ModerateRoutinely blunting inflammation after training with ice baths or high-dose anti-inflammatories has been shown to reduce muscle and strength gains over time. Manage pain; do not reflexively suppress it.
Read the evidenceReturn-to-sport readiness testing
Evidence: ModeratePain relief alone is not a reliable readiness test. Restored strength symmetry (around 90% of the uninjured side), demonstrated load tolerance, time, and psychological readiness all matter more.
Read the evidenceNSAIDs (ibuprofen) after injury
Evidence: PreliminaryShort-term NSAID use can help with pain, but higher doses and prolonged use may slow fracture healing, impair tendon-to-bone repair, and blunt muscle adaptation.
Read the evidenceCollagen + vitamin C before loading (tendons & ligaments)
Evidence: PreliminaryCollagen with vitamin C taken before loading raises collagen-synthesis markers and helped in one small Achilles tendinopathy trial, but the effects are modest, so treat it as a minor adjunct to loading, not a replacement for it.
Read the evidenceBPC-157 for tendon healing
Evidence: PreclinicalBPC-157 consistently speeds tendon healing in rodent studies, but no published randomized human trials exist, so its effect in people remains unproven. It is not an approved medication and is banned in regulated sport.
Read the evidenceHealing peptides overview (BPC-157, TB-500, GHK-Cu)
Evidence: PreclinicalBPC-157, TB-500, and GHK-Cu all show regenerative activity in laboratory and animal models (GHK-Cu also has cosmetic-grade human skin data), but none has well-powered human trials for musculoskeletal healing.
Read the evidence
The evidence digest
Twice a month we send a short briefing on what new research actually means for your health. Unsubscribe anytime.
Educational content only. Not a substitute for medical advice.